Vladimir Illich Ulyanov ( Lenin) was born in Simbirsk, Russia, on 10th April, 1870. His father,
Ilya Ulyanov, a local schools inspector, held conservative views and was a
devout member of the Russian Orthodox Church. Lenin was deeply influenced by
the revolutionary political views of his older brother, Alexander Ulyanov, who
introduced him to the ideas of Karl Marx.
Lenin was educated at the
Simbirsk Gymnasium. His headmaster was Fyodor Kerensky, the father of Alexander
Kerensky. Although Lenin despised the conservative views of his teachers he
still managed to do well in his examinations.
At the of seventeen Lenin read
the utopian novel, What is to be Done? by Nikolai Chernyshevsky. Along with
Alexander Ulyanov and Karl Marx, Chernyshevsky was the greatest influence on
his early political development. In 1887 Lenin's brother, Alexander Ulyanov, a
member of the People's Will, was executed for his part in the plot to kill Tsar
Alexander III. As the brother of a state criminal, attempts were made to stop
Lenin from entering university. Eventually he was allowed to study law at Kazan
University.
While at university Lenin became
involved in politics. After one protest demonstration he was arrested and taken
to the local police station. One of the police officers asked: "Why are
you rebelling, young man? After all, there is a wall in front of you."
Lenin confidently replied: "The wall is tottering, you only have to push
it for it to fall over." Lenin was now expelled from Kazan University and
so he went to St. Petersburg and studied as an external student. After passing
his law exams in 1891, Lenin started practising law in Samara.
Lenin returned to St. Petersburg
in 1893. He continued his involvement in politics and in 1895 went to
Switzerland to meet George Plekhanov, Pavel Axelrod, Vera Zasulich and Lev
Deich and other members of the Liberation of Labour group. When Lenin returned
to Russia, Lenin and a group of friends, including Jules Martov and Nadezhda
Krupskaya, formed the Union of Struggle for the Emancipation of the Working
Class.
In 1896 Lenin was arrested and
sentenced to three years internal exile in Siberia. His close colleague,
Nadezhda Krupskaya, joined Lenin in Shushenskoye and they married in July,
1898. While living in exile Lenin wrote The Development of Capitalism in
Russia, The Tasks of Russian Social Democrats, as well as articles for various
socialist journals. Lenin and Krupskaya also translated from English to
Russian, The Theory and Practice of Trade Unionism by Sidney Webb and Beatrice
Webb.
Released in February, 1900,
Lenin, Nadezhda Krupskaya and Jules Martov decided to leave Russia. They moved
to Geneva where they joined up with George Plekhanov, Pavel Axelrod and other
members of the Liberation of Labour to publish Iskra (Spark). The paper was
named after a passage from a poem: "The spark will kindle a flame".
Others who joined the venture included Gregory Zinoviev, Leon Trotsky and Vera
Zasulich. Another revolutionary, Clara Zetkin, arranged for Iskra to be printed
in Leipzig. The newspaper now became the official journal of the Social
Democratic Labour Party, an organization that attempted to unite all socialist
groups in favour of the overthrow of the autocracy in Russia.
In 1902 Lenin published a
pamphlet, What Is To Be Done? where he argued for a party of professional
revolutionaries dedicated to the overthrow of Tsarism. He continued to argue
the case for a small party of activists with a large fringe of non-party
sympathizers and supporters at the Second Congress of the Social Democratic
Labour Party held in London in 1903.
His long-time friend, Jues
Martov, disagreed believing it was better to have a large party of activists.
Martov won the vote 28-23 but Lenin was unwilling to accept the result and
formed a faction known as the Bolsheviks. Those who remained loyal to Martov
became known as Mensheviks. Lenin now lost control of Iskra and therefore
launched his own newspaper, Vperyod (Forward).
Lenin's supporters in the Social
Democratic Labour Party included Gregory Zinoviev, Joseph Stalin, Anatoli
Lunacharsky, Mikhail Lashevich, Nadezhda Krupskaya, Alexei Rykov, Yakov
Sverdlov, Mikhail Frunze, Maxim Litvinov, Vladimir Antonov, Felix Dzerzhinsky,
Gregory Ordzhonikidze, and Alexander Bogdanov. Whereas George Plekhanov, Pavel
Axelrod, Leon Trotsky, Lev Deich, Vladimir Antonov-Ovseenko, Vera Zasulich,
Irakli Tsereteli, Moisei Uritsky, Noi Zhordania and Fedor Dan supported Jules
Martov.
Lenin came under attack from the
Marxist philosopher, Rosa Luxemburg. In 1904 she published Organizational
Questions of the Russian Democracy, where she argued: "Lenin’s thesis is
that the party Central Committee should have the privilege of naming all the
local committees of the party. It should have the right to appoint the
effective organs of all local bodies from Geneva to Liege, from Tomsk to
Irkutsk. It should also have the right to impose on all of them its own
ready-made rules of party conduct... The Central Committee would be the only
thinking element in the party. All other groupings would be its executive
limbs." Luxemburg diagreed with Lenin's views on centralism and suggested
that any successful revolution that used this strategy would develop into a
communist dictatorship.
Lenin returned to Russia during
the 1905 Revolution but unlike Leon Trotsky and the Mensheviks, he made little
impact on its development and failed to gain much support from the emerging
trade union movement. In 1907 Lenin abandoned hope for an imminent armed
uprising and called on Bolsheviks in Russia to participate in the elections for
the Third Duma.
Lenin also spent a great deal of
time finding ways of raising money for the party. He secured large donations
from Maxim Gorky and Sava Morozov, the Moscow millionaire. This was not the
main source of income. The armed hold-ups of Bolsheviks gangs provided much
more. One raid on the Tiflis Post Office raised 250,000 roubles. The gang used
bombs during the robbery and several people were killed. When George Plekhanov,
one of the leaders of the Mensheviks, heard that the Bolsheviks were behind the
robbery he declared: "The whole affair is so outrageous that it is really
high time for us to break off all relations with the Bolsheviks."
Lenin, and his two loyal
assistants, Gregory Zinoviev and Lev Kamenev, used this money to print
revolutionary literature and newspapers such as Zvezda. Some money was used to
gain control some of the unions that were emerging in Russia's main industrial
cities. One of Lenin's agents, Roman Malinovsky, was elected as general
secretary of the St Petersburg Metalworkers' Union.
In 1911, Lenin, Gregory Zinoviev,
Lev Kamenev and other Bolsheviks moved to France and settled in a small village
just outside of Paris. They were joined by Inessa Armand. According to Nadezhda
Krupskaya: "She (Inessa) was a very ardent Bolshevik and soon gathered our
Paris crowd around her." They set up a Bolshevik Party School where agents
were trained before returning to Russia. They also made plans to capture
control of the Social Democratic Labour Party at the conference to be held in
Prague in January, 1912. This move was unsuccessful and the party split and
after that date the Bolsheviks maintained a completely separate existence from
the Mensheviks.
At the Prague conference in 1912
Lenin suggested that Roman Malinovsky should join the Bolshevik Central
Committee. Some party members opposed this move, claiming that there were rumours
that Malinovsky was an Okhrana agent. He refused to believe the charges and
advocated that Malinovsky should also be a Bolshevik candidate for the Duma.
After being elected in October, 1912, Malinovsky became the leader of the group
of six Bolshevik deputies. Malinovsky became known as an eloquent and forceful
orator. Before making his speeches he sent copies to Lenin and S. P. Beletsky,
the director of Okhrana.
Inessa Armand became very close
to Lenin. According to Bertram D. Wolfe, the author of Strange Communists I
Have Known (1966): "She had a wider culture than any other woman in
Lenin's circle (at least until Kollontay became an adherent of his during the
war), a deep love of music, above all of Beethoven, who became Lenin's favorite
too. She played the piano like a virtuoso, was fluent in five languages, was
enormously serious about Bolshevism and work among women, and possessed
personal charm and an intense love of life to which almost all who wrote of her
testify."
Others like Angelica Balabanoff
thought that she became too much a follower of Lenin: "I did not warm to
Inessa. She was pedantic, a one hundred per cent Bolshevik in the way she
dressed (always in the same severe style), in the way she thought, and spoke.
She spoke a number of languages fluently, and in all of them repeated Lenin
verbatim."
After being elected in October,
1912, Roman Malinovsky became the leader of the group of six Bolshevik
deputies. Lenin argued: "For the first time among ours in the Duma there
is an outstanding worker-leader. He will read the Declaration (the political
declaration of the Social Democratic fraction on the address of the Prime
Minister). This time it's not another Alexinsky. And the results - perhaps not
immediately - will be great."
Malinovsky was now in a position
to spy on Lenin. This included supplying Okhrana with copies of his letters. In
a letter dated 18th December, 1912, S.E. Vissarionov, the Assistant Director of
Okhrana, wrote to the Minister of the Interior: "The situation of the Fraction
is now such that it may be possible for the six Bolsheviks to be induced to act
in such a way as to split the Fraction into Bolsheviks and Mensheviks. Lenin
supports this. See his letter (supplied by Malinovsky)".
Rumours continued to circulate
that Roman Malinovsky was a spy working for Okhrana. This included an anonymous
letter sent to Fedor Dan about Malinovsky's activities. When Elena Troyanovsky
was arrested in 1913 her husband wrote a letter claiming that if she was not
released he would expose the double agent in the leadership of the Bolsheviks.
S. P. Beletsky later testified that when he showed this letter to Malinovsky he
"became hysterical" and demanded that she was released. In order that
he remained as a spy Beletsky agreed to do this.
According to Bertram D. Wolfe in
1913: "He (Malinovsky) was entrusted with setting up a secret printing
plant inside Russia, which naturally did not remain secret for long. Together
with Yakovlev he helped start a Bolshevik paper in Moscow. It, too, ended promptly
with the arrest of the editor. Inside Russia, the popular Duma Deputy traveled
to all centers. Arrests took place sufficiently later to avert suspicion from
him... The police raised his wage from five hundred to six hundred, and then to
seven hundred rubles a month."
Another Bolshevik leader, Nikolai
Bukharin, became convinced that Malinovsky was a spy. David Shub has argued:
"There was a wave of arrests among the Bolsheviks in Moscow. Among those
rounded up was Nikolai Bukharin... Bukharin, then a member of the Moscow
Committee of the Bolshevik Party, had distrusted Malinovsky from the start,
despite the latter's assiduous attempts to win his confidence. For Bukharin had
noticed several times that when he arranged a secret rendezvous with a party
comrade, Okhrana agents would be waiting to pounce on him. In each case
Malinovsky had known of the appointments and the men whom Bukharin was to meet
had been arrested."
Bukharin wrote to Lenin claiming
that when he was hiding in Moscow he was arrested by the police just after a
meeting with Malinovsky. He was convinced that Malinovsky was a spy. Lenin
wrote back that if Bukharin joined in the campaign of slander against
Malinovsky he would brand him publicly as a traitor. Understandably, Bukharin
dropped the matter.
Nadezhda Krupskaya later
explained: "Vladimir Ilyich thought it utterly impossible for Malinovsky
to have been an agent provocateur. These rumors came from Menshevik circles...
The commission investigated all the rumors but could not obtain any definite
proof of the charge." Instead of carrying out an investigation into
Malinovsky, Lenin launched an attack on Julius Martov and Fedor Dan, who he
accused of acting like "gossipy old women".
In 1913 Lenin and Nadezhda
Krupskaya moved to Galicia in Austria. He organized a conference of Bolshevik
leaders in Zakopane in August. It was later discovered that of the twenty-two
men who attended, five, including Roman Malinovsky, were Okhrana agents.
In the autumn of 1913, Inessa
Armand joined Lenin in Galicia. According to Angelica Balabanoff, Inessa and
Lenin were now lovers: "Lenin loved Inessa. There was nothing immoral in
it, since Lenin told Krupskaya everything. He deeply loved music, and this
Krupskaya could not give him. Inessa played beautifully his beloved Beethoven
and other pieces... He had had a child by Inessa." This story is also
supported by the testimony of Alexandra Kollontai.
Nadezhda Krupskaya wrote about
her relationship with Inessa Armand in her book, Reminisces on Lenin (1926):
"In the autumn (of 1913) all of us became very close to Inessa. In her
there was much joy of life and ardor. We had known Inessa in Paris, but there
was a large colony there. In Krakow lived a small closely knit circle of comrades.
Inessa rented a room in the same family with which Kamenev lived... It became
cosier and gayer when Inessa came. Our entire life was filled with party
concerns and affairs, more like a student commune than like family life, and we
were glad to have Inessa... Something warm radiated from her talk."
In 1914 another Bolshevik leader,
Nikolai Bukharin, became convinced that Roman Malinovsky was a spy. David Shub
has argued: "There was a wave of arrests among the Bolsheviks in Moscow.
Among those rounded up was Nikolai Bukharin... Bukharin, then a member of the
Moscow Committee of the Bolshevik Party, had distrusted Malinovsky from the
start, despite the latter's assiduous attempts to win his confidence. For
Bukharin had noticed several times that when he arranged a secret rendezvous
with a party comrade, Okhrana agents would be waiting to pounce on him. In each
case Malinovsky had known of the appointments and the men whom Bukharin was to
meet had been arrested."
Bukharin wrote to Lenin claiming
that when he was hiding in Moscow he was arrested by the police just after a
meeting with Malinovsky. He was convinced that Malinovsky was a spy. Lenin
wrote back that if Bukharin joined in the campaign of slander against
Malinovsky he would brand him publicly as a traitor. Understandably, Bukharin
dropped the matter.
In June 1914 Lenin published an
article in Prosveshchenie: "We do not believe one single word of Dan and
Martov.... We don't trust Martov and Dan. We do not regard them as honest
citizens. We will deal with them only as common criminals - only so, and not
otherwise... If a man says, make political concessions to me, recognize me as
an equal comrade of the Marxist community or I will set up a howl about rumors
of the provocateur activity of Malinovsky, that is political blackmail. Against
blackmail we are always and unconditionally for the bourgeois legality of the
bourgeois court... Either you make a public accusation signed with your
signature so that the bourgeois court can expose and punish you (there are no other
means of fighting blackmail), or you remain as people branded... as slanderers
by the workers."
Roman Malinovsky resigned from
the Duma on the outbreak of the First World War and against the orders of the
Bolsheviks he joined the Russian Army. He was wounded and captured by the
German Army in 1915 and spent the rest of the conflict in a prisoner of war
camp. Surprisingly, in December 1916, the Bolshevik newspaper, Sotsial
Demokrat, reported that Malinovsky had been "fully rehabilitated" for
his past crime of "desertion of his post".
Lenin was appalled by the
decision of most socialists in Europe to support the war effort. He now devoted
his energies to campaign to turn the "imperialist war into a civil
war". This included the publication of his book, Imperialism: The Highest
Stage of Capitalism. Along with his close collaborators, Gregory Zinoviev and
Lev Kamenev, Lenin arranged for the distribution of propaganda that urged
Allied troops to turn their rifles against their officers and start a socialist
revolution.
Lenin argued that "the
slogan of peace is wrong - the slogan must be, turn the imperialist war into
civil war." Lenin believed that a civil war in Russia would bring down the
old order and enable the Bolsheviks to gain power. This brought him into
conflict with Rosa Luxemburg. In 1915 Luxemburg published the highly
influential pamphlet, The Crisis in the German Social Democracy. Luxemburg
rejected the view of the Social Democratic Party leadership that the war would
bring democracy to Russia: "It is true that socialism gives to every
people the right of independence and the freedom of independent control of its
own destinies. But it is a veritable perversion of socialism to regard
present-day capitalist society as the expression of this self-determination of
nations. Where is there a nation in which the people have had the right to
determine the form and conditions of their national, political and social
existence?"
Luxemburg also pointed out that
Germany was also fighting democratic states such as Britain and France:
"Germany certainly has not the right to speak of a war of defence, but
France and England have little more justification. They too are protecting, not
their national, but their world political existence, their old imperialistic possessions,
from the attacks of the German upstart." To Luxemburg, this was an
imperialist war, not a war of political liberation.
In the pamphlet Rosa Luxemburg
quoted Friedrich Engels as saying: “Bourgeois society stands at the crossroads,
either transition to socialism or regression into barbarism.” She added:
"A look around us at this moment shows what the regression of bourgeois
society into barbarism means. This world war is a regression into barbarism....
The world war today is demonstrably not only murder on a grand scale; it is
also suicide of the working classes of Europe. The soldiers of socialism, the
proletarians of England, France, Germany, Russia, and Belgium have for months
been killing one another at the behest of capital. They are driving the cold
steel of murder into each other’s hearts. Locked in the embrace of death, they
tumble into a common grave."
Lenin disagreed with this desire
to bring the First World War to an end and sent Inessa Armand to the
International Socialist Bureau conference in Brussels "to do battle with
such large figures" such as Karl Kautsky, Rosa Luxemburg, George
Plekhanov, Leon Trotsky, Julius Martov, Emile Vandervelde and Camille Huysmans.
As Bertram D. Wolfe pointed out: "He counted on her mastery of all the languages
of the International, her literal devotion to him and his views, her
steadfastness under fire."
In September 1915, Nicholas II
assumed supreme command of the Russian Army fighting on the Eastern Front. This
linked him to the country's military failures and during 1917 there was a
strong decline support for his government. The country's incompetent and
corrupt system could not supply the necessary equipment to enable the Russian
Army to fight a modern war. By 1917 over 1,300,000 men had been killed in
battle, 4,200,000 wounded and 2,417,000 had been captured by the enemy.
The war also had a disastrous
impact on the Russian economy. Food was in short supply and this led to rising
prices. By January 1917 the price of commodities in Petrograd had increased
six-fold. In an attempt to increase their wages, industrial workers went on
strike and in Petrograd people took to the street demanding food. On 11th
February, 1917, a large crowd marched through the streets of Petrograd breaking
shop windows and shouting anti-war slogans.
On 26th February Nicholas II
ordered the Duma to close down. Members refused and they continued to meet and
discuss what they should do. Michael Rodzianko, President of the Duma, sent a
telegram to the Tsar suggesting that he appoint a new government led by someone
who had the confidence of the people. When the Tsar did not reply, the Duma
nominated a Provisional Government headed by Prince George Lvov.
The High Command of the Russian
Army now feared a violent revolution and on 28th February suggested that
Nicholas II should abdicate in favour of a more popular member of the royal
family. Attempts were now made to persuade Grand Duke Michael Alexandrovich to
accept the throne. He refused and on the 1st March, 1917, the Tsar abdicated
leaving the Provisional Government in control of the country.
Lenin was now desperate to return
to Russia to help shape the future of the country. The German Foreign Ministry,
who hoped that Lenin's presence in Russia would help bring the war on the Eastern
Front to an end, provided a special train for Lenin and 27 other Bolsheviks to
travel to Petrograd. The journalist, Harold Williams rejected the idea that
Lenin could play an important role in affairs: "Lenin, leader of the
extreme faction of the Social Democrats, arrived here on Monday night by way of
Germany. His action in accepting from the German government a passage from
Switzerland through Germany arouses intense indignation here. He has come back
breathing fire, and demanding the immediate and unconditional conclusions of
peace, civil war against the army and government, and vengeance on Kerensky and
Chkheidze, whom he describes as traitors to the cause of International
Socialism. At the meeting of Social Democrats yesterday his wild rant was received
in dead silence, and he was vigorously attacked, not only by the more moderate
Social Democrats, but by members of his own faction. Lenin was left absolutely
without supporters. The sharp repulse given to this firebrand was a healthy
sign of the growth of practical sense of the Socialist wing, and the generally
moderate and sensible tone of the conference of provincial workers' and
soldiers' deputies was another hopeful indication of the passing of the
revolutionary fever."
Ariadna Tyrkova, a member of the
Constitutional Democrat Party, commented: "He (Lenin) was a Marxist for
whom the theory of the class-struggle was an irrefutable dogma, entitling its
adepts to hold in contempt all scruples of conscience and all demands of logic.
From his youth his revolutionary work was characterised by the spirit of cold
intrigue and by the cruel arrogance of a man convinced that he was the bearer
of absolute truth, and, therefore, absolved from all moral obligations.
Ambitious and domineering, utterly unscrupulous in his choice of means, Lenin
acted upon the principles of Divide et impera and sowed discord among his own
party. It was he who broke up the party into the two factions of Bolsheviks and
Mensheviks at the beginning of the twentieth century. The difference between
those factions lies chiefly in their tactics, or rather in their moral
standard."
When Lenin returned to Russia on
3rd April, 1917, he announced what became known as the April Theses. Lenin
attacked Bolsheviks for supporting the Provisional Government. Instead, he
argued, revolutionaries should be telling the people of Russia that they should
take over the control of the country. In his speech, Lenin urged the peasants
to take the land from the rich landlords and the industrial workers to seize
the factories.
Albert Rhys Williams got to know
Lenin during this period. He later argued: "He was the most thoroughly
civilized and humane man I ever have known, as nice a one as I ever knew, in
addition to being a great man." Williams was convinced that the Bolsheviks
would become the new rulers: "The Bolsheviks understood the people. They
were strong among the more literate strata, like the sailors, and comprised
largely the artisans and labourers of the cities. Sprung directly from the people's
lions they spoke the people's language, shared their sorrows and thought their
thoughts. They were the people. So they were trusted."
Lenin accused those Bolsheviks
who were still supporting the Provisional Government of betraying socialism and
suggested that they should leave the party. Some took Lenin's advice, arguing
that any attempt at revolution at this stage was bound to fail and would lead
to another repressive, authoritarian Russian government.
Joseph Stalin was in a difficult
position. As one of the editors of Pravda, he was aware that he was being held
partly responsible for what Lenin had described as "betraying
socialism". Stalin had two main options open to him: he could oppose Lenin
and challenge him for the leadership of the party, or he could change his mind
about supporting the Provisional Government and remain loyal to Lenin.
After ten days of silence, Stalin
made his move. In Pravda he wrote an article dismissing the idea of working
with the Provisional Government. He condemned left-wing members of the
government such as Alexander Kerensky and Victor Chernov as
counter-revolutionaries, and urged the peasants to form committees to prepare
to takeover the land for themselves.
On 8th July, 1917, Alexander
Kerensky became the new leader of the Provisional Government. In the Duma he
had been leader of the moderate socialists and had been seen as the champion of
the working-class. However, Kerensky, like his predecessor, George Lvov, was
unwilling to end the war. In fact, soon after taking office, he announced a new
summer offensive.
Soldiers on the Eastern Front
were dismayed at the news and regiments began to refuse to move to the front
line. There was a rapid increase in the number of men deserting and by the
autumn of 1917 an estimated 2 million men had unofficially left the army. Some
of these soldiers returned to their homes and used their weapons to seize land
from the nobility. Manor houses were burnt down and in some cases wealthy
landowners were murdered. Kerensky and the Provisional Government issued
warnings but were powerless to stop the redistribution of land in the
countryside.
Lenin welcomed these developments
and it became clear to Alexander Kerensky that the Bolshevik posed a real
threat to his government. On 19th July, Kerensky gave orders for the arrest of
Lenin as well as Gregory Zinoviev, Lev Kamenev, Anatoli Lunacharsky, and
Alexandra Kollontai. The Bolshevik headquarters at the Kshesinsky Palace, was
also occupied by government troops.
A Bolshevik spy in the Ministry
of Justice discovered what was going to happen and Lenin was able to escape to
nearby Finland where he was hidden by a secret socialist, the Helsinki chief of
police. While in Finland Lenin completed State and Revolution. In the book
Lenin explained his ideas of the kind socialist government he would like to see
in Russia.
After the failure of the July
Offensive on the Eastern Front, the prime minister, Alexander Kerensky,
replaced General Alexei Brusilov with General Lavr Kornilov, as Supreme
Commander of the Russian Army. The two men soon clashed about military policy.
Kornilov wanted Kerensky to restore the death-penalty for soldiers and to
militarize the factories.
Lavr Kornilov responded by
sending troops under the leadership of General Krymov to take control of
Petrograd. Alexander Kerensky was now in danger and was forced to ask the
Soviets and the Red Guards to protect Petrograd. The Bolsheviks, who controlled
these organizations, agreed to this request, but Lenin made clear they would be
fighting against Kornilov rather than for Kerensky.
Within a few days Bolsheviks had
enlisted 25,000 armed recruits to defend Petrograd. While they dug trenches and
fortified the city, delegations of soldiers were sent out to talk to the
advancing troops. Meetings were held and Kornilov's troops decided not to
attack Petrograd. General Krymov committed suicide and Kornilov was arrested
and taken into custody.
Lenin now returned to Petrograd
but remained in hiding. On 25th September, Kerensky attempted to recover his
left-wing support by forming a new coalition that included more Mensheviks and
Socialist Revolutionaries. However, with the Bolsheviks controlling the Soviets
and now able to call on 25,000 armed militia, Kerensky's authority had been
undermined.
Morgan Philips Price, a
journalist working for the Manchester Guardian, watched Lenin and Leon Trotsky
closely during this period: "Lenin struck me as being a man who, in spite
of the revolutionary jargon that he used, was aware of the obstacles facing him
and his party. There was no doubt that Lenin was the driving force behind the
Bolshevik Party... He was the brains and the planner, but not the orator or the
rabble-rouser. That function fell to Trotsky. I watched the latter, several
times that evening, rouse the Congress delegates, who were becoming listless,
probably through long hours of excitement and waiting. He was always the man
who could say the right thing at the right moment. I could see that there was
beginning now that fruitful partnership between him and Lenin that did so much
to carry the Revolution through the critical periods that were coming."
The Bolsheviks set up their
headquarters in the Smolny Institute. The former girls' convent school also
housed the Petrograd Soviet. Under pressure from the nobility and
industrialists, Alexander Kerensky was persuaded to take decisive action. On
22nd October he ordered the arrest of the Bolshevik Military Revolutionary
Committee. The next day he closed down the Bolshevik newspapers and cut off the
telephones to the Smolny Institute.
Leon Trotsky now urged the
overthrow of the Provisional Government. Lenin agreed and on the evening of
24th October, 1917, orders were given for the Bolsheviks began to occupy the
railway stations, the telephone exchange and the State Bank. The following day
the Red Guards surrounded the Winter Palace. Inside was most of the country's
Cabinet, although Kerensky had managed to escape from the city.
The Winter Palace was defended by
Cossacks, some junior army officers and the Woman's Battalion. At 9 p.m. the
Aurora and the Peter and Paul Fortress began to open fire on the palace. Little
damage was done but the action persuaded most of those defending the building
to surrender. The Red Guards, led by Vladimir Antonov-Ovseenko, now entered the
Winter Palace and arrested the Cabinet ministers.
On 26th October, 1917, the
All-Russian Congress of Soviets met and handed over power to the Soviet Council
of People's Commissars. Lenin was elected chairman and other appointments
included Leon Trotsky (Foreign Affairs) Alexei Rykov (Internal Affairs),
Anatoli Lunacharsky (Education), Alexandra Kollontai (Social Welfare), Felix
Dzerzhinsky (Internal Affairs), Joseph Stalin (Nationalities), Peter Stuchka
(Justice) and Vladimir Antonov-Ovseenko (War).
As chairman of the Council of
People's Commissars, Lenin abolished private ownership of land and began
distributing it among the peasants. Banks were nationalized and workers control
of factory production was introduced. He also closed down the Constituent
Assemby and began banning political parties such as the Cadets, Mensheviks and
the Socialist Revolutionaries.
On 8th November, 1917, John Reed
spent time with Lenin: "A short, stocky figure, with a big head set down
in his shoulders, bald and bulging. Little eyes, a snubbish nose, wide, generous
mouth, and heavy chin; clean-shaven now, but already beginning to bristle with
the well-known beard of his past and future. Dressed in shabby clothes, his
trousers much too long for him. Unimpressive, to be the idol of a mob, loved
and revered as perhaps few leaders in history have been. A strange popular
leader 'a leader purely by virtue of intellect; colourless, humourless,
umcompromising and detached, without picturesque idiosyncracies - but with the
power of explaining profound ideas in simple terms, of analysing a concrete
situation. And combined with shrewdness, the greatest intellectual
audacity."
Several of the communist leaders
in Germany, including Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht were arrested and
imprisoned during the First World War. While in prison Luxemburg wrote The
Russian Revolution, where she criticized Lenin for using the dictatorial and
terrorist methods to overthrow the government in Russia. "Terror has not
crushed us. How can you put your trust in terror."
Once again this work showed that
she was opposed to the activities of the Bolsheviks. She quotes Leon Trotsky as
saying: "As Marxists we have never been idol worshippers of formal
democracy.” She replied that: "All that that really means is: We have
always distinguished the social kernel from the political form of bourgeois
democracy; we have always revealed the hard kernel of social inequality and
lack of freedom hidden under the sweet shell of formal equality and freedom –
not in order to reject the latter but to spur the working class into not being
satisfied with the shell, but rather, by conquering political power, to create
a socialist democracy to replace bourgeois democracy – not to eliminate
democracy altogether."
Rosa Luxemburg went onto argue:
"But socialist democracy is not something which begins only in the
promised land after the foundations of socialist economy are created; it does
not come as some sort of Christmas present for the worthy people who, in the
interim, have loyally supported a handful of socialist dictators. Socialist
democracy begins simultaneously with the beginnings of the destruction of class
rule and of the construction of socialism. It begins at the very moment of the
seizure of power by the socialist party. It is the same thing as the dictatorship
of the proletariat. Yes, dictatorship! But this dictatorship consists in the
manner of applying democracy, not in its elimination, but in energetic,
resolute attacks upon the well-entrenched rights and economic relationships of
bourgeois society, without which a socialist transformation cannot be
accomplished. But this dictatorship must be the work of the class and not of a
little leading minority in the name of the class – that is, it must proceed
step by step out of the active participation of the masses; it must be under
their direct influence, subjected to the control of complete public activity;
it must arise out of the growing political training of the mass of the
people."
Lenin also demobilized the army
and announced that he planned to seek an armistice with Germany. In December,
1917, Leon Trotsky led the Russian delegation at Brest-Litovsk that was
negotiating with representatives from Germany and Austria.
Trotsky had the difficult task of
trying to end Russian participation in the First World War without having to
grant territory to the Central Powers. By employing delaying tactics Trotsky
hoped that socialist revolutions would spread from Russia to Germany and
Austria-Hungary before he had to sign the treaty.
After nine weeks of discussions
without agreement, the German Army was ordered to resume its advance into
Russia. On 3rd March 1918, with German troops moving towards Petrograd, Lenin
ordered Trotsky to accept the terms of the Central Powers. The Brest-Litovsk
Treaty resulted in the Russians surrendering the Ukraine, Finland, the Baltic
provinces, the Caucasus and Poland.
The decision increased opposition
to the Bolshevik government and General Lavr Kornilov now organized a Volunteer
Army. Over the next few months other groups who opposed the Soviet regime
joined the struggle. Eventually these soldiers who fought against the Red Army
during the Civil War became known as the Whites.
Those that joined the White Army
included the Cadets, who wished to continue the war against the Central Powers.
Some Mensheviks and Socialist Revolutionaries that were opposed to the
dictatorial powers of the new regime also joined the resistance. Others who
opposed the Bolsheviks included landowners who had lost their estates, factory
owners who had their property nationalized, devout members of the Russian
Orthodox Church who objected to the government's atheism and royalists who
wanted to restore the monarchy.
The White Army initially had
success in the Ukraine where the Bolsheviks were unpopular. The main resistance
came from Nestor Makhno, the leader of an Anarchist army in the area. Leon
Trotsky and Vladimir Antonov-Ovseenko, led the Red Army and gradually
pro-Bolsheviks took control of the Ukraine. By February, 1918, the Whites held
no major areas in Russia but it was not until late 1920 that the Civil War came
to an end.
On 2nd November, 1918, Roman
Malinovsky crossed the Russian border and turned up in Petrograd. He visited
the Smolny Institute, the Bolshevik headquarters, on three days running, demanding
to be taken to see Lenin. On the third day, Gregory Zinoviev saw him and
ordered his arrest. He was taken to Moscow for trial and Nikolai Krylenko was
appointed as prosecutor.
Vladimir Burtsev interviewed
Malinovsky and he told him: "When the Revolution triumphed in Germany and
Russia and the possibility of participating prominently in political activities
was lost to him forever, he decided to go back and die, rather than to flee
into the obscurity of an Argentina or a similar place of refuge. Of course, he
could have committed suicide, but he preferred to die in the view of everybody,
and had no fear of death."
At his trial Roman Malinovsky
admitted he had been a spy and commented: "I am not asking for mercy! I
know what is in store for me. I deserve it." After a brief trial was found
guilty and executed that night. The historian, Bertram D. Wolfe, has asked the
following questions: "How much did Lenin know of Malinovsky's past? Why
did Lenin exonerate Malinovsky in 1914, against the evidence and against the
world? Why did he rehabilitate him in 1916? Why did Malinovsky return to Russia
when Lenin was in power? Did he count on Lenin? Why did Lenin then not lift a
finger to save him?"
Inessa Armand contracted cholera
and died at the age of forty-six on 24th September 1914. Angelica Balabanoff
recorded that: "Lenin was utterly broken by her death... He was plunged in
despair, his cap down over his eyes; small as he was, he seemed to shrink and
grow smaller. He looked pitiful and broken in spirit. I never saw him look like
that before." Alexandra Kollontai added: "He was not able to go on
living after Inessa Armand. The death of Inessa hastened the development of the
sickness which was to destroy him."
Lenin's policy of War Communism
during the Civil War created social distress and led to riots, strikes and
demonstrations. After the Kronstadt Uprising he responded by introducing the
New Economic Policy. Farmers were allowed to sell food on the open market and
were allowed to employ people to work for them. Those farmers who expanded the
size of their farms became known as kulaks. Factories employing less than
twenty people were denationalized and could be claimed back by former owners.
Lenin's health declined after
being shot by Dora Kaplan, a member of the Socialist Revolutionaries, on 30th
August, 1918. Two bullets entered his body and it was too dangerous to remove
them. In a statement she made to Cheka that night, she explained that she had
attempted to kill him because he had closed down the Constituent Assembly and
described him as a "traitor to the revolution."
Lenin found the disagreements
over the New Economic Policy exhausting. His health had been poor ever since
Dora Kaplan had shot him in 1918. Severe headaches limited his sleep and
understandably he began to suffer from fatigue. Lincoln Steffens interviewed
Lenin after he was shot by Dora Kaplan: "Lenin was impatient with my
liberalism, but he had shown himself a liberal by instinct. He had defended
liberty of speech, assembly, and the Russian press for some five to seven
months after the October revolution which put him in power. The people had
stopped talking; they were for action on the program. But the plottings of the
whites, the distracting debates and criticisms of the various shades of reds,
the wild conspiracies and the violence of the anarchists against Bolshevik
socialism, developed an extreme left in Lenin's party which proposed to proceed
directly to the terror which the people were ready for. Lenin held out against
them till he was shot, and even then, when he was in hospital, he pleaded for
the life of the woman who shot him."
Lenin decided he needed someone
to help him control the Communist Party. At the Party Conference in April,
1922, Lenin suggested that a new post of General Secretary should be created.
Lenin's choice for the post was Joseph Stalin, who in the past had always
loyally supported his policies. Stalin's main opponents for the future
leadership of the party failed to see the importance of this position and
actually supported his nomination. They initially saw the post of General
Secretary as being no more that "Lenin's mouthpiece".
Soon after Stalin's appointment
as General Secretary, Lenin went into hospital to have a bullet removed from
his body that had been there since Dora Kaplan's assassination attempt. It was
hoped that this operation would restore his health. This was not to be; soon
afterwards, a blood vessel broke in Lenin's brain. This left him paralyzed all
down his right side and for a time he was unable to speak. As "Lenin's
mouthpiece", Joseph Stalin had suddenly become extremely important.
While Lenin was immobilized,
Stalin made full use of his powers as General Secretary. At the Party Congress
he had been granted permission to expel "unsatisfactory" party
members. This enabled Stalin to remove thousands of supporters of Leon Trotsky,
his main rival for the leadership of the party. As General Secretary, Stalin
also had the power to appoint and sack people from important positions in the
government. The new holders of these posts were fully aware that they owed
their promotion to Stalin. They also knew that if their behaviour did not
please him they would be replaced.
Surrounded by his supporters,
Stalin's confidence began to grow. In October, 1922, he disagreed with Lenin
over the issue of foreign trade. When the matter was discussed at Central
Committee, Stalin's rather than Lenin's policy was accepted. Lenin began to
fear that Stalin was taking over the leadership of the party. Lenin wrote to
Leon Trotsky asking for his support. Trotsky agreed and at the next meeting of
the Central Committee the decision on foreign trade was reversed. Lenin, who
was too ill to attend, wrote to Trotsky congratulating him on his success and
suggesting that in future they should work together against Stalin.
Joseph Stalin, whose wife Nadya
Alliluyeva worked in Lenin's private office, soon discovered the contents of
the letter sent to Leon Trotsky. Stalin was furious as he realized that if
Lenin and Trotsky worked together against him, his political career would be at
an end. In a fit of temper Stalin made an abusive phone-call to Lenin's life,
Nadezhda Krupskaya, accusing her of endangering Lenin's life by allowing him to
write letters when he was so ill.
After Krupskaya told her husband
of this phone-call, Lenin made the decision that Stalin was not the man to
replace him as the leader of the party. Lenin knew he was close to death so he
dictated to his secretary a letter that he wanted to serve as his last
"will and testament". The document was comprised of his thoughts on
the senior members of the party leadership.
He was particularly concerned about the
growing power of Joseph Stalin: "Comrade Stalin, having become General
Secretary, has concentrated enormous power in his hands: and I am not sure that
he always knows how to use that power with sufficient caution. I therefore
propose to our comrades to consider a means of removing Stalin from this post
and appointing someone else who differs from Stalin in one weighty respect:
being more tolerant, more loyal, more polite, more considerate of his
comrades."
Three days after writing this
testament Lenin had a third stroke. Lenin was no longer able to speak or write
and although he lived for another ten months, he ceased to exist as a power
within the Soviet Union.
Lenin died in Gorki on 21st
January, 1924.
No comments:
Post a Comment